China Plans a Nationwide Carbon Market

China recently confirmed its plan to place the entire nation under a carbon market (cap-and-trade regime) to lower its annual rate of emitting carbon dioxide (CO₂), the important greenhouse gas, beginning in 2016.

 

• China intends to continue lowering its carbon intensity, i.e., the amount of CO₂ emitted for each US$ of gross domestic product (GDP) that the economy produces.

 

• The goal is to reduce the carbon intensity by 40-45% below the 2005 value by 2020.  Averaged over this 15-year period, this corresponds to a reduction of 2.7-3% per year.  This can arise from increased efficiencies in energy production and use from fossil fuels, and by increased production of energy from renewable sources.

 

• While this accomplishment would be highly significant, the objective does not directly address China’s total CO₂ emission rate.

 

• China’s net annual rate of emitting CO₂ is projected to grow between 2014 and 2040, with much of the increase occurring in the period up to 2020 (see the graphic below).

 

Global projected energy-related carbon dioxide emission rates per year to 2040.  RED, China.  OECD, Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development, representing already industrialized countries of the world; “rest of OECD” excludes the U. S.  Non-OECD represents developing countries of the world; “rest of non-OECD” excludes China and India.

Source: http://www.eia.gov/countries/cab.cfm?fips=CH

 

 

• The average growth rate for China’s energy-related CO₂ emissions from 2010 to 2020 is about 5.3% per year, comparable to the growth in overall energy consumption, about 5.5% per year.  Note that these objective data already reflect any improvements in carbon intensity.

 

• The national carbon market envisioned for China would be far larger than any other carbon market operating in the world today.

 

Significance

 

Cap-and-trade systems are one of two principal strategies for limiting greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions (especially CO₂); the other is a direct tax on carbon-containing fuels.  Cap-and-trade regimes limit emissions by capping each year’s allowed amount of GHG emissions, and lowering the cap each year.  Low-efficiency facilities can acquire more allowances from more efficient ones by trading on an open market or exchange, thus establishing a price for emissions. 

 

A small number of cap-and-trade regimes exists already.  They have varying degrees of effectiveness.  The European Union’s Emission Trading System was highly ineffective for several years because it distributed too large a number of allowances.  The U. S. has not enacted any federal law regulating GHG emissions.  Recently, however, President Obama’s administration has raised efficiency requirements for vehicles and has issued draft rules limiting emissions from electric power plants.  The Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative, in nine northeastern American states, operates an effective system, but one which is limited both in its goals and because it applies only to large electric power generators.  The state of California is implementing a significant cap-and-trade regime covering its entire energy economy. 

 

As noted above, China’s national cap-and-trade system will be the largest in the world by far.

 

China has been the world’s largest emitter of GHGs since 2009.   China is projected to dramatically increase its overall energy consumption over the period 2010-2040, continuing its rapid growth in use of energy in recent years (see the graphic below).  Most is supplied by fossil fuels.

 



Annual rates of energy usage for China, the U. S. and India.  Actual use up to 2010; projected usage thereafter.  1 quadrillion = 1 million billion.  Btu, British thermal unit.

Source: U. S. Energy Information Administration; http://www.eia.gov/pressroom/presentations/sieminski_07252013.pdf (slide 5).

 

The drastic increase in China’s energy consumption in recent years has resulted in a corresponding growth in its annual rate of CO₂ emissions.  Projecting forward over the period 2010-2040 the Energy Information Administration believes the emissions growth rate will average about 2.1% per year.

 

A major factor contributing to China’s high rates of CO₂ emissions is its reliance on coal to provide almost 70% of its energy.  Of all the fossil fuels, burning coal emits 50% to 90% more CO₂ than the others in order to obtain the same amount of heat energy.

 

China’s Five Year Plans (FYPs) have programmed in the changes detailed here. 

According to the report “Delivering Low Carbon Growth – A Guide to the 12th Five Year Plan”, during the 12^th FYP, covering 2011-2015, the carbon intensity was to improve by 17%, and the 13^th FYP (2016-2020) already included the reduction of 40-45% with respect to the carbon intensity of 2005 mentioned at the outset.  The proportion of energy provided by non-fossil fuels is to be 11.4% in the 12^th FYP and 15.0% in the 13^th FYP.  The actual increase in primary energy consumption was 6.3% per year in the 11^th FYP, and intended to be 3.75-5% in the 12^th FYP.

 

Market-based incentives.  Already during the 12^th FYP China set up 7 regional and provincial pilot cap-and-trade projects, placing limits on CO₂ emissions.  The experience gained from these pilots is to provide useful background for setting up the nationwide system.

 

China and other developing countries, together with developed countries, have to agree to meaningful reductions in the world’s GHG emissions that are currently being negotiated under the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change.  China, for one, has emphasized its achievements in lowering its carbon intensity, even though its use of fossil fuels has been increasing resulting in increased annual rates of GHG emissions.   Agreement on a new emissions treaty is intended during 2015, and it is foreseen to enter into force by 2020.  All nations of the world should approach these negotiations in good faith, and strive to achieve agreement on meaningful reductions in GHG emissions.

© 2014 Henry Auer